A year ago, I was concerned about my 9 yo ds's writing. He has really progressed, so now we have almost the opposite problem. While creative writing is still a challenge for him, he is enjoying the written history narrations each week. We are in unit 24 of PHFHG. Today he was asked to write 3-5 sentences about Charlemagne. After editing for one run-on, he ended up with 9 sentences.
"During the uneducated Dark Ages, there lived a Frank king named Charlemagne. A puzzling thing about Charlemagne is that he wore simple clothes and ate common food. In fact, he went hunting with his nobles during a storm just so he could laugh at them and not have the joke on him. But what makes it funny is that he lived in a gorgeous palace. He had no education, so he invited a British monk named Alcuin to teach him. Although he learned to read, Charlemagne never learned to write. To prevent others from making the same mistake, he ordered every monastery to have a school in it. Furthermore he raised his daughters in the arts of sewing and spinning. In the Dark Ages, Charlemagne was surely a light."
So do I work with him on editing down to 3-5 sentences by eliminating details, or let him write as much as he wants at this point? Though it could use further editing, I think what he wrote is wonderfully detailed. My concern is about the "3-5 sentence" guideline. Is the purpose to make sure the child is writing enough, or to prevent them from rewriting the entire selection? or both?
Appreciate any insight you wonderful ladies can offer.
PHFHG written narration question
-
- Posts: 5
- Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2012 8:59 pm
PHFHG written narration question
Nancy
11 yo ds - Res to Ref
8 yo ds - PHFHG
3 yo ds - LHTH 1/2 speed
11 yo ds - Res to Ref
8 yo ds - PHFHG
3 yo ds - LHTH 1/2 speed
Re: PHFHG written narration question
Oh my goodness, this is fabulous! I would let him write as much as he wants. In my opinion the guideline is to get them to write enough and also keep them from just copying what they read. If he starts writing anything much longer you might want to gently remind him it's not intended to be quite so long, but I feel this was excellent.
Melissa (Pastor's wife in NC)
http://gracefilledhomeschooling.blogspot.com
Rose (12-years-old) - Revival to Revolution
Beth (10-years-old) - Creation to Christ
Grace (8-years-old) - Bigger Hearts for His Glory
http://gracefilledhomeschooling.blogspot.com
Rose (12-years-old) - Revival to Revolution
Beth (10-years-old) - Creation to Christ
Grace (8-years-old) - Bigger Hearts for His Glory
Re: PHFHG written narration question
Sounds like a great narration. My kiddos are in Preparing and I have made them stick to the 3-5 sentence thing. Now I'm wondering if it is okay to do more.
Edwena
*Married to my best friend for 16 yrs
*Mom to ds (15), dd (13), dd #2(3)
*Combining my dc in WG (2017-2018)
*Completed and absolutely loved BLHFHG through MTMM
*Married to my best friend for 16 yrs
*Mom to ds (15), dd (13), dd #2(3)
*Combining my dc in WG (2017-2018)
*Completed and absolutely loved BLHFHG through MTMM
-
- Posts: 247
- Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2007 1:37 pm
- Location: AL
Re: PHFHG written narration question
I think the 3-5 sentence is a minimum. I would not have him edit that narration. My oldest writes longer narrations than my younger.
Amy
T-18 Masters degree Cyber Security WGU
T-16 Bachelors in Cyber Security WGU
A-12 Res to Ref
A-10 Res to Ref
Heart of Dakota user since 2007.
T-18 Masters degree Cyber Security WGU
T-16 Bachelors in Cyber Security WGU
A-12 Res to Ref
A-10 Res to Ref
Heart of Dakota user since 2007.