A few years ago, I took my kids to private art lessons, at $10 per kid, plus $2 each for supplies. The lessons were taught by a retired public school teacher. Honestly, some of the lessons my kids did privately were identical to projects that were assigned in the pages of Beyond and Bigger.
I remember specifically one artistic expression lesson that was taught in Bigger on symmetry. It's been awhile, but if I remember correctly, the kids were supposed to make a navajo blanket. The instructions were to fold a piece of paper in half and draw identical designs on each side of the paper, working out from the center. Doesn't sound like much does it? The kids did the assignment and we put it in the notebook and that was that. When the kids were given a similar assignment and I paid $22 for it, I wanted to scream.
I don't know. Taking private lessons and paying all that money really gave me a different perspective on things. We finished the year out, but decided not to continue. Rather than spend the money on lessons, I decided to put that cash toward supplies. The art teacher liked the children to work with Sharpies. I happen to agree. The colors are so much more vibrant than regular markers and they're fun to work with. She also had a great pencil sharpener, and I noticed her color pencils were never dull. I bought a good pencil sharpener and wow, what a time saver.
Another great thing I learned from her was this -- always work on good quality paper, and draw a 1/2 inch border around the edges. Use the blue paint tape to secure the paper to an artist board. Hobby Lobby has foam board for $1.99 and it goes on sale for half price. All you need to do is cut it in half or further down to a more manageable size. It gives the kids a nice surface to work on. When they're done with their project, remove the tape, and the white contrasting border helps the finished art work to look more professional. This is especially beneficial when doing watercolor painting because it helps keep paper flat and it dries nicer.
I don't think of this as "craft time". The lessons in the Artistic Expression boxes are teaching the kids legitimate skills. I paid a high price to figure it out.
HOD truly offers a thoroughly well thought out lesson plan on all levels.