Post
by momofjka » Mon Apr 18, 2011 8:23 am
I am going to be homeschooling for the first time this year coming up, and went through the EXACT same questions as you. My DS will be 9 and going into 4th grade and "placed" on the chart for Preparing too. He is very smart in History, Science, and English and has been using Abeka for the last 4 years of private school. But everyone told me that Bigger would be the better level for my DS because there is more writing and independent work in Preparing, he had never done dictation or oral/written narrations, and because Charlotte Mason style of teaching/learning was new for us both. I think we could have made Preparing work for us, but along with the above, my other concern was that he would be in CTC the following year (which is more intense and has even more independent work and writing)...and I wasn't sure he'd be ready for that. So after alot of prayer, I ordered Bigger with Singapore Math 2A/2B, R&S 3 (he could have done 4, but w/ switching curriculums I wanted to make sure there were no gaps), and DITHOR 2/3. I had been really concerned that Bigger wouldn't be enough to challenge him because he is very smart (he has always scored several grade levels above on the SAT's) and makes high grades at school. But after getting the materials in, I think it will be perfect for us.
I agree with momtoJGJE, it really depends on what you've used for past materials and the style of teaching you've done. I think Bigger "as is" to start would be fine (you could always add the extensions later if you find your DD needs more) and maybe order the guide for Preparing (we did this just to use for the English and for the dictation. Then I will already have it for next year!)
If your DD has never done Singapore Math, you should also go to the Singapore math website and have her do the placement test...(just be sure to use the one for US edition, not standard... they are not the same). I was surprised at where my DS placed, but Singapore Math is more advanced than other programs. Hope this helps... biggest thing to do is use the placement chart, get council, and PRAY! God will direct you to the right level for your DS.
Jennifer
Wife of Jim
Mom of:
Jason (10) PHFHG
Katrina (7) BLHFHG
Anthony (5) LHFHG
Vincent (Born 4/23/2012)