I was just wondering if it would be better for them to do the Storytime box individually or if they would benefit more by doing it together. I know there isn't a right or wrong answer here, just wondering what you ladies that have already "been there, done that" think? My dc are only 17 months apart in age with the ds being the oldest of the two. They are currently on the same level of Motor Skills & Math even though I do Math with them individually most of the time. They are both in the same book in Phonics but my ds is ahead of my dd. I had to actually stall my dd in Phonics because my ds was struggling. I felt it was more important that ds learned to read before dd for confidence reasons. Thanks in advance!!
I have picked up some at our library for a quarter!! I also request specific books for my dc for gifts as well. I am just glad that they love books as much as I do!! 
. You can always read some more titles at night if you'd like, but otherwise, one thing we did for my oldest ds (once he was old enough to read well independently) is put whatever books we didn't read for previous Storytimes in a basket under his bed for him to read at his leisure. He has loved this! In fact, we're doing it again with the CTC books that are Boy/Girl picks, since we chose to do the History Interest for Storytime. I just feel sad at the idea of them missing such good books, but I don't have the time (nor inclination 
) to read more than 1 right now. So, this is a way I never feel like they're missing out. Just an idea to keep in your back pocket! 
I think I will stick to one book for storytime and just add in the others for fun! That is working fine in LHFHG. So if it isn't broke, don't fix it!!