I have homeschooled for the last 7 years with the Charlotte Mason method. I have been pretty eclectic in my book choices and lately have used SL in a CM way. My kids are 11, 9,7 and 4 (the only girl).
I have to say I was drawn to HOD because our farm is close to South Dakota in SW Minnesota--we are by Walnut Grove, MN. Right now we are on a military base in AL, but we are Minnesota farmers at heart. Anyway, I had no idea that HOD had used CM methods or I would have looked long ago.

Yesterday I purchased Little Hearts and Bigger because my homeschool consignment store had then and after seeing them I had to have them! We were doing Sonlight core 1+2 and core 5 and I was getting very burned out. Last year we did Sonlight core 3 (American history) so some of BIgger is review, but I thought that would be nice anyway. I want to do HOD over the summer and see how it goes. I am printing off the first history books so I can start today.
Here are my questions. My oldest is 11 and will continue with Apologia General Science through the summer and his core 5 readers (hopefully I will add DITHOR for him at some point) along with his math and Intermediate Langugage Lessons/ DGP Grammar. Would be be ok to do Bigger with his younger brothers if he keeps up his own English, math and science? I thought I could have him do copywork from the poems and hymns along with his brothers too, but he is pretty used to dictation already. My other question is what book would my oldest go into next if I wanted to start him in an older book next year? Is it best to go to Preparing or Hearts for Him?
Thanks, we are going to start our first HOD day.

Blessings,
Carrie