Hi

I found that the guides b/4 CTC took about 2-3 hours a day, total. My teaching time was not too long, but I did have to be available to help sometimes. Carrie has a post somewhere, talking about how she has everyone doing math, etc. at the table together and she does some work nearby so she can help if needed. I feel that our days went better doing 3 guides than they did with kids combined....this is because I spent more time trying to explain more mature content to the youngest, while having to come up with meaningful work to challenge the oldest. With HOD and proper placement, this is not an issue, and each child is now getting what they need. Yes, it is a long day now that I have a highschooler, but that is what we chose to do

We have mostly independent 9th and 7th graders, and very dependant 5th grader now in remediation

I wish I had just followed the guides as written with proper placement all along

Really, it seems intimidating until you get things going, then you relax and just follow the guides. Many ladies stagger their starts so as to get their older dc going well, then working with the younger dc. Hope you find your best plan

, though the guides you mentioned seem like a good one. (BTW, we really enjoyed Uncovering the Mysterious Woolly Mammoth in Preparing extension...it is a "prequel" for Life in the Great Ice Age.)