my3sons wrote:...To clarify, the sequence Carrie has written for the science is the preferred sequence.

So, between the 2 choices being discussed here, for 8th grade, doing physical science with Exploration Education would first be recommended. For 9th grade, doing IPC would be recommended...
Hi ladies! I realized I should add to my post to mention that the reason only RevtoRev's science choice and WG's science choice was discussed was due to the original question about choosing between these two options. So, to 'clarify' the clarification

for others reading this, doing the science sequence as it is written in HOD, including MTMM's science within the sequence, would be the intended path for students to take...
RevtoRev...
Physical Science Focus
Daily independent readings, experiments, and activities in the area of physical science, combine living books about inventors with Education Exploration's lab-driven science course. Students build real-life projects to experiment with force, electricity, energy, current, motion, properties and changes in matter, speed, velocity, pressure, density, buoyancy, magnetism and electromagnets, motors, generators, circuitry, physical and chemical reactions, transfer of energy, sound, optics, light, and more.
MTMM...
Introduction to Chemisty & Creation vs. Evolution Focus:
Daily independent readings about chemistry, 20th century scientists, and creation vs.evolution are combined with experiments and activities in the areas of chemistry, genetics, & DNA. Students experiment with reactions between solids, liquids, and gases; effects of acids and bases: electrochemical reactions with metals and salts; isolating DNA from a tomato; investigating inheritance and how traits are passed down; showing dominant and recessive genes through game play; learning the components of cells; building a model of the double-stranded helical structure of DNA; finding out how nucleotides fit together; analyzing DNA evidence; breeding a bacteria colony; discovering how mutation affects genes; and much more!
WG...
Integrated Physics & Chemistry with Lab Focus
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=12932
We have completed the science as planned from year to year and found it to be excellent! I hope you enjoy it as well!
In Christ,
Julie