I had just as much fun with LHFHG the second time, and it felt very different because our oldest and middle ds are about as different as day and night!

I did it along with Bigger Hearts too. It's very doable - I found it ideal to have blocks of time both dc are working, one with me, one more independently (the independent one would be the Bigger Hearts child primarly

), as well as blocks of time where they worked at different tables and I popped back and forth between them to oversee their work (good for math and grammar type work). HTH!
As far as your phonics question, I haven't done that program, but since no one's responded I will try to help. I am familiar with Reading Made Easy, but not the details of it. I'd say if you are to make the worms in front of them progressively, and that's a part of the learning, I'd remake them. If it's not the making of them but rather used as a reference, I'd just use the ones you made. Or, if you are able to cover the upcoming segments with sticky notes and take them off to "reveal" the words as you go (and that doesn't take away from the learning), I'd do that. Does that help at all?

If not, maybe someone else who has used Reading Made Easy will respond.
In Christ,
Julie