Kinda Sorta Don't Like...
Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2008 9:08 am
I kind of don't like a coupe of aspects on LHFHG. Don't yell at me! : ) REALLY please don't be upset, these are only my opinions.
Let me preface by saying I LOVE LHTH & LHFHG.
I am a reading specialist, and I am critical of reading & phonics. I admit it.
I wish that we didn't just do Burgess stories. One reason is the type of dialect they use (accents & such) expose kids to SO much of the same type of writing. ( A Year's worth).
I totally get that we can ALSO read other books on our own time ... Miss Piggle Wiggle or The Hundred Dresses or Mr. Poppers Penguins. I would like to be told what to read and given suggestions for topics to discuss after each chapter...but...I would like more variety in authors & type of dialect used.
Additionally, I feel Reddy Fox needs some background information on characters. It is confusing to not know who they are.
I think this age group is still in need of really classic picture books as well...Mike Mulligan, A Chair For My Mother, Ferdinand, Tom Thumb, Tikki Tikki Tembo, and the like. These stories are GREAT for enriching retelling and (optional) enrichment projects.
***
The second thing I don't like is the recommended phonics resources. I have both of them. Though their is no perfect system, I think Reading Made Easy and The Reading Lesson both have flaws that are pretty big.
I know it is important to give folks affordable choices. However, giving some less affordable choices that are more sound is an option too. I have suggestions if you like One program I really like is Scaredy Cat Reading, but there are many others I like as well.
***
I would like to see some more math choices recommended by HOD. Again, I understand that Singapore is inexpensive. But when you read reviews, so many people don't like it. And it has VERY little options for hands on kids.
Though HOD doesn't have to offer these necessarily, maybe it could recommend some alternate programs. Right Start Math, Math U See (both expensive). Saxon (especially for upper grades), Teaching Textbooks...
Let me reiterate my love for HOD and it's products! I am a faithful user!
Thanks for listening!
Let me preface by saying I LOVE LHTH & LHFHG.
I am a reading specialist, and I am critical of reading & phonics. I admit it.
I wish that we didn't just do Burgess stories. One reason is the type of dialect they use (accents & such) expose kids to SO much of the same type of writing. ( A Year's worth).
I totally get that we can ALSO read other books on our own time ... Miss Piggle Wiggle or The Hundred Dresses or Mr. Poppers Penguins. I would like to be told what to read and given suggestions for topics to discuss after each chapter...but...I would like more variety in authors & type of dialect used.
Additionally, I feel Reddy Fox needs some background information on characters. It is confusing to not know who they are.
I think this age group is still in need of really classic picture books as well...Mike Mulligan, A Chair For My Mother, Ferdinand, Tom Thumb, Tikki Tikki Tembo, and the like. These stories are GREAT for enriching retelling and (optional) enrichment projects.
***
The second thing I don't like is the recommended phonics resources. I have both of them. Though their is no perfect system, I think Reading Made Easy and The Reading Lesson both have flaws that are pretty big.
I know it is important to give folks affordable choices. However, giving some less affordable choices that are more sound is an option too. I have suggestions if you like One program I really like is Scaredy Cat Reading, but there are many others I like as well.

***
I would like to see some more math choices recommended by HOD. Again, I understand that Singapore is inexpensive. But when you read reviews, so many people don't like it. And it has VERY little options for hands on kids.
Though HOD doesn't have to offer these necessarily, maybe it could recommend some alternate programs. Right Start Math, Math U See (both expensive). Saxon (especially for upper grades), Teaching Textbooks...
Let me reiterate my love for HOD and it's products! I am a faithful user!
Thanks for listening!