We are somewhat new to HoD. I used Carrie's first two guides when my girls were little. It has been awhile and I have used mostly history textbooks from Christian Liberty Press beefed up with living books for the varied ages of our four kiddos. The other subjects are as follows--Bible (CLP), grammar (Rod and Staff), science (living books), and creative writing and literature I have taught without a "specific purchased" guide. Other things taught here and there mostly centering around our travels. We are a military family.
Our children's ages are dd14, dd12, ds10 and ds9. I am trying to focus mostly on the needs of my 14 yr old who will be considered 9th grade this year. We have enough from this past year to create a 9th grade transcript but I did not like the science we choose to use and I ended up scrapping it mid year. I supplemented other books but we lacked in lab work. She technically would have been 8th this past year anyway. So...I am looking at the new Geography and it seems wonderful. My concern is not having used HoD in any recent years she may struggle to keep up. She is a very independent learner and naturally picks things up quickly. I have also sensed a real desire in her heart for more "freedoms" in the home. The right kind of freedoms like branching out in her God given talents, more home management and local missions. It could be a good thing for her to be more independent this coming school year. The other option would be to start with Rev2Rev or MtMM (hope I got those right) and progress from there through her four years. I am not sure how to count those as high school credit but I will be using a different science as well as R & S 7.
Now...how about the other 3 kiddos?I really don't want to have to buy 2 packages ($$$$) but I want all to receive the best learning experience possible. I am willing to eat PB&J for awhile
!!Any suggestions will be appreciated. I have done nothing but read these boards and look at HoD books for two weeks!! I have to make a decision and move on!
Thanks a bunch!
In His Grip,
Kim
If your daughter did high school level work last year in everything including science with the exception of lab, science could still be high school worthy depending on the state you live in. Here in Ohio, you only need 3 lab sciences for graduation requirements. So as long as the science had enough rigor and hours to it, it could be counted if it fits in the science categories of your state (ie. physical science, chemistry, biology, A&P, etc). I'm sure the other ladies on this board will chime in. IMO, they are some of the most gracious and humble women in their responses to need of other moms 
