Hi Paige,
My heart goes out to you, because I think we have all been there especially every time we have a two year old in the house…. I think you have gotten some good replies and I have really appreciated reading them, since I too have a two year old ds. I hesitate to add my own reply, because I feel kind of “un-qualified” but I will let you know some of the things I do, or try to do, at our house. In addition, I am going to pray that you will receive some clarity from the HS.
Okay, so here it goes.
I like to use the word “routine” rather than “schedule”. Schedule inherently implies to me that a specific event or activity should happen at a specific time of day. But “routine” implies to me that a series of activities happen in the same order even if they do not always happen at the exact same time. Exact time would be ideal, but for me, “life happens.”
For a “routine” example:
dc may not come out of their rooms before 7:00am (working to 7:30am)
wake up, get dressed, eat, family worship at the breakfast table (most often includes our
LHFHG left page) (great when ds2.5 has food in his mouth…), brush teeth, clean table, do dishes. I take a very short “break” from children to gather our lessons... then ds5 does math for 20-30 minutes while ds2.5 plays in playroom in adjacent room (open, no walls—which can distract us…), then ds5 takes a 30-45 minute break
while ds2.5 has 15-20 minute “blanket time” which is his own personal “learning time” with mommy on a blanket on the living room floor (great place for our BFIAR activity, a puzzle, LHTH activity, music, or a game ). Then mommy takes a very short “breather”. Then it is time for ds5 to do Reading/Phonics lesson
for 20-30 minutes while ds2.5 plays in his room down the hall with the door shut.
(variation: IF ds2.5 is able to sit with us and color without distracting, we try. He is loud and makes lots of noise just to hear himself so this often does not work. As soon as I have had enough of his distracting us, he knows he must leave the table to a place with boundaries like his room with the door shut for the rest of the 20 minute lesson of ds5. He is growing into this “room time” so it is a work in progress. He does pretty well, but it is something we have worked on from “day one”.
So if I now go back and attach a time to these activities, my “routine” then becomes a “schedule”. I do have times that I attach to my routine activities, but the goal is to do basically the same activities in the same order. I allow myself some flexibility: like 30 or 45 minutes leeway, but there are, what I call, “hard breaks” like lunch. Lunch must happen at 11:30a or 12N so that
my ds2.5 can go down for his nap at 12:30-1:00pm (
the pre-nap routine is another good one-on-one time with mommy for 20-30 minutes before nap time). We are alone together in his room in our special chair and do our read-aloud from BFIAR or LHTH activities. Then he goes down for nap. It has always been this way and I guard this time every day so there is not much resistance -- yet

.
Eventually, as he gets older, nap time turns into rest time which becomes afternoon room time when he is older. When I come out of ds2.5’s room after putting him down for his nap, I then take a short breather for myself. Then around 1:30pm or 2:00pm, I do another short lesson time with ds5. Then he has a break and around 3:30pm he must observe his own room-time for 60-90 minutes. He is able to come out of his room for bathroom. If he comes out for other reasons, I add 15 minutes. There is a real clock in his room in addition to a “dummy” clock that shows the time which his room-time ends. When the two clocks match, he can come out. As it turns out, this has been a great way to learn the clock !
I am so sorry if this rambles and is confusing. I have not used MOTH, but I have it on my shelf ! I will tell you that my husband and I took a wonderful in-depth parenting class at our church that gave me most of these ideas. Like any diet or exercise plan, I may not have agreed with one hundred percent or followed one-hundred percent of the suggested “diet”, but we did get a lot of very practical tips to apply to specific everyday situations. The name of the parenting class was Growing Kids God’s Way and the secular version is the Parent-Wise series by titles such as ToddlerWise, PreSchool Wise, and ChildWise. I hesitate to even mention them because they receive a lot of criticism, but I will tell you that
while I may not have agreed with one hundred percent of what was in the books, I found them to offer some very practical suggestions on specific behaviors my children were having. There is a separate parenting ministry which also has some material with other practical tips by Joey & Carla Link related to GKGW.
The great thing is that there are books out there by many different authors written through the ages to fit each family's unique and special needs so please understand I am not asserting that these GKGW books would help every family, but that they helped me with mine.
There are a lot of other good parenting books out there, but the hard part is having the time to read them once you find them. I have several others in my home library waiting in “queue” to be read. Anyway, I hope this helps someone who might come across it.