I'm looking at Rev to Rev for my rising 6th grader for next year. We also do Classical Conversations and I want to keep my kids doing the same history (next year will be US and US geography.). My DS who will be in 4th grade next year is totally ready for an independent guide but not yet for RtR. I've got to keep him in US history though. With some adapting, Bigger could be great for him. He could read all the material independently. He already moves through his lessons very much on his own. He could do more than Bigger though, notebooking and history projects. But the reading in Rev to Rev would be too much for him.
I did a few of the younger guides with my kids many years ago. It will not work for us now if I have to lead them in a guide and they are ready to do this on their own. How can I make this work?